| “Yesterday” | The Beatles | Rachel Berry | 1. “Love, Love, Love” |
| “Drive My Car” | The Beatles | Artie Abrams and Kitty Wilde with New Directions | 1. “Love, Love, Love” |
| “Got to Get You into My Life” | The Beatles | Kurt Hummel and Blaine Anderson with the McKinley High marching band | 1. “Love, Love, Love” |
| “You’ve Got to Hide Your Love Away” | The Beatles | Artie Abrams and Kitty Wilde | 1. “Love, Love, Love” |
| “Help!” | The Beatles | Blaine Anderson and Sam Evans with New Directions, Vocal Adrenaline, Haverbrook School for the Deaf and Dalton Academy Warblers | 1. “Love, Love, Love” |
| “A Hard Day’s Night” | The Beatles | Rachel Berry and Santana Lopez with Spotlight Diner co-workers | 1. “Love, Love, Love” |
| “I Saw Her Standing There” | The Beatles | Blaine Anderson, Sam Evans, Jake Puckerman and Ryder Lynn | 1. “Love, Love, Love” |
| “All You Need Is Love” | The Beatles | Blaine Anderson with New Directions, Dalton Academy Warblers, Vocal Adrenaline, Haverbrook School for the Deaf, Rachel Berry, Burt Hummel, Mercedes Jones, Santana Lopez and Will Schuester | 1. “Love, Love, Love” |
| “Revolution” | The Beatles | Tina Cohen-Chang | 2. “Tina in the Sky with Diamonds” |
| “Get Back” | The Beatles | Kurt Hummel and Rachel Berry with NYADA students | 2. “Tina in the Sky with Diamonds” |
| “Something” | The Beatles | Sam Evans with Ryder Lynn and Jake Puckerman | 2. “Tina in the Sky with Diamonds” |
| “Here Comes the Sun” | The Beatles | Dani and Santana Lopez | 2. “Tina in the Sky with Diamonds” |
| “Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band” | The Beatles | Jake Puckerman, Ryder Lynn, Wade “Unique” Adams and Marley Rose | 2. “Tina in the Sky with Diamonds” |
| “Hey Jude” | The Beatles | Blaine Anderson, Kitty Wilde, Tina Cohen-Chang and Sam Evans with New Directions | 2. “Tina in the Sky with Diamonds” |
| “Let It Be” | The Beatles | Rachel Berry, Santana Lopez, Kurt Hummel and New Directions | 2. “Tina in the Sky with Diamonds” |
| “Seasons of Love” | Rent | Mercedes Jones, Santana Lopez, Kurt Hummel, Noah Puckerman, Tina Cohen-Changand New Directions | 3. “The Quarterback” |
| “I’ll Stand by You” | The Pretenders | Mercedes Jones with New Directions | 3. “The Quarterback” |
| “Fire and Rain” | James Taylor | Artie Abrams and Sam Evans with New Directions | 3. “The Quarterback” |
| “If I Die Young” | The Band Perry | Santana Lopez with New Directions | 3. “The Quarterback” |
| “No Surrender” | Bruce Springsteen | Noah Puckerman | 3. “The Quarterback” |
| “Make You Feel My Love” | Adele | Rachel Berry | 3. “The Quarterback” |
| “Marry the Night” | Lady Gaga | Elliott “Starchild” Gilbert | 4. “A Katy or a Gaga” |
| “Applause” | Lady Gaga | Sam Evans, Blaine Anderson, Artie Abrams, Ryder Lynn and Marley Rose | 4. “A Katy or a Gaga” |
| “Wide Awake” | Katy Perry | Jake Puckerman, Tina Cohen-Chang, Kitty Wilde and Wade “Unique” Adams | 4. “A Katy or a Gaga” |
| “Roar” | Katy Perry | Tina Cohen-Chang, Wade “Unique” Adams, Kitty Wilde, Sam Evans, Rachel Berry, Elliott “Starchild” Gilbert, Dani and Santana Lopez with New Directions and Kurt Hummel | 4. “A Katy or a Gaga” |
| “You Are Woman, I Am Man” | Funny Girl | Paolo San Pablo and Rachel Berry | 5. “The End of Twerk” |
| “Blurred Lines” | Robin Thicke feat. T.I.and Pharrell | Will Schuester, Artie Abrams, Jake Puckerman and Bree with New Directions and McKinley High students | 5. “The End of Twerk” |
| “If I Were a Boy” | Beyoncé | Wade “Unique” Adams | 5. “The End of Twerk” |
| “Wrecking Ball” | Miley Cyrus | Marley Rose | 5. “The End of Twerk” |
| “On Our Way” | The Royal Concept | New Directions | 5. “The End of Twerk” |
| “Movin’ Out (Anthony’s Song)” | Billy Joel | Blaine Anderson and Sam Evans with New Directions | 6. “Movin’ Out” |
| “Piano Man” | Billy Joel | Blaine Anderson with Spotlight Diner patrons and employees | 6. “Movin’ Out” |
| “My Life” | Billy Joel | Jake Puckerman with New Directions females and the McKinley High Cheerios | 6. “Movin’ Out” |
| “Honesty” | Billy Joel | Artie Abrams | 6. “Movin’ Out” |
| “An Innocent Man” | Billy Joel | Ryder Lynn | 6. “Movin’ Out” |
| “Just the Way You Are” | Billy Joel | Kurt Hummel, Blaine Anderson, Rachel Berry, Sam Evans and Santana Lopez | 6. “Movin’ Out” |
| “You May Be Right” | Billy Joel | Will Schuester, Artie Abrams, Kitty Wilde, Ryder Lynn and Jake Puckerman with New Directions and McKinley High students | 6. “Movin’ Out” |
| “Into the Groove” | Madonna | Pamela Lansbury | 7. “Puppet Master” |
| “You’re My Best Friend” | Queen | Blaine Anderson with New Directions puppets | 7. “Puppet Master” |
| “Nasty” / “Rhythm Nation” | Janet Jackson | Jake Puckerman, Marley Rose and Bree with the McKinley High Cheerios | 7. “Puppet Master” |
| “Cheek to Cheek” | Fred Astaire | Will Schuester and Sue Sylvester | 7. “Puppet Master” |
| “The Fox (What Does the Fox Say?)” | Ylvis | New Directions and Pamela Lansbury | 7. “Puppet Master” |
| “Here Comes Santa Claus” | Bing Crosby and The Andrews Sisters | Kurt Hummel, Santana Lopez and Rachel Berry with mall elves | 8. “Previously Unaired Christmas” |
| “Rockin’ Around the Christmas Tree” | Brenda Lee | Artie Abrams, Will Schuester, Jake Puckerman, Kitty Wilde and Marley Rose with New Directions | 8. “Previously Unaired Christmas” |
| “Mary’s Boy Child” | Boney M. | Marley Rose, Wade “Unique” Adams and Tina Cohen-Chang | 8. “Previously Unaired Christmas” |
| “The Chipmunk Song (Christmas Don’t Be Late)” | Alvin and the Chipmunks | Rachel Berry, Kurt Hummel and Santana Lopez with Cody Tolentino | 8. “Previously Unaired Christmas” |
| “Love Child” | Diana Ross & the Supremes | Wade “Unique” Adams with Tina Cohen-Chang, Marley Rose and New Directions except Kitty Wilde | 8. “Previously Unaired Christmas” |
| “Away in a Manger” | Traditional | Santana Lopez, Rachel Berry, Kurt Hummel and Kitty Wilde with New Directions | 8. “Previously Unaired Christmas” |
| “Whenever I Call You Friend” | Kenny Loggins andStevie Nicks | Artie Abrams and Tina Cohen-Chang with New Directions | 9. “Frenemies” |
| “Brave” | Sara Bareilles | Santana Lopez and Rachel Berry | 9. “Frenemies” |
| “My Lovin’ (You’re Never Gonna Get It)” | En Vogue | Artie Abrams and Tina Cohen-Chang with New Directions and Will Schuester | 9. “Frenemies” |
| “Beautiful Dreamer” | Stephen Foster | Funny Girl understudy auditionee | 9. “Frenemies” |
| “Don’t Rain on My Parade” | Funny Girl | Santana Lopez | 9. “Frenemies” |
| “I Believe in a Thing Called Love” | The Darkness | Elliott “Starchild” Gilbert and Kurt Hummel | 9. “Frenemies” |
| “Every Breath You Take” | The Police | Rachel Berry and Santana Lopez | 9. “Frenemies” |
| “Breakaway” | Kelly Clarkson | Tina Cohen-Chang, Artie Abrams and Blaine Anderson with New Directions | 9. “Frenemies” |
| “Jumpin’, Jumpin'” | Destiny’s Child | Tina Cohen-Chang, Blaine Anderson and Sam Evans | 10. “Trio” |
| “Barracuda” | Heart | Elliott “Starchild” Gilbert and Rachel Berry | 10. “Trio” |
| “Don’t You (Forget About Me)” | Simple Minds | Sam Evans, Blaine Anderson and Tina Cohen-Chang | 10. “Trio” |
| “Danny’s Song” | Loggins and Messina | Will Schuester and Emma Pillsbury | 10. “Trio” |
| “Gloria” | Laura Branigan | Santana Lopez, Elliott “Starchild” Gilbert and Rachel Berry | 10. “Trio” |
| “The Happening” | The Supremes | Kurt Hummel, Dani and Elliott “Starchild” Gilbert | 10. “Trio” |
| “Hold On” | Wilson Phillips | Tina Cohen-Chang, Blaine Anderson, Artie Abrams, Sam Evans, Kurt Hummel, Elliott “Starchild” Gilbert, Rachel Berry, Santana Lopez and Dani | 10. “Trio” |
| “I Love L.A.” | Randy Newman | Will Schuester, Blaine Anderson, Artie Abrams, Sam Evans and Jake Puckerman with New Directions | 11. “City of Angels” |
| “Vacation” | The Go-Go’s | The Amazonians | 11. “City of Angels” |
| “Mr. Roboto” / “Counting Stars” | Styx / OneRepublic | Jean-Baptiste and Throat Explosion | 11. “City of Angels” |
| “More Than a Feeling” | Boston | Blaine Anderson, Tina Cohen-Chang and New Directions | 11. “City of Angels” |
| “America” | Neil Diamond | New Directions | 11. “City of Angels” |
| “I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For” | U2 | Sam Evans and New Directions | 11. “City of Angels” |
| “Raise Your Glass” | Pink | April Rhodes and Will Schuester with original and current New Directions members | 12. “100” |
| “Toxic” | Britney Spears | Quinn Fabray, Santana Lopez and Brittany Pierce | 12. “100” |
| “Defying Gravity” | Wicked | Mercedes Jones, Kurt Hummel and Rachel Berry | 12. “100” |
| “Valerie” | Mark Ronson feat.Amy Winehouse | Santana Lopez and Brittany Pierce with Mike Chang and Jake Puckerman | 12. “100” |
| “Keep Holding On” | Avril Lavigne | Noah Puckerman with original and current New Directions members | 12. “100” |
| “Happy” | Pharrell Williams | Holly Holliday, April Rhodes, Will Schuester, Blaine Anderson and Mercedes Jones with original and current New Directions members | 12. “100” |
| “I Am Changing” | Dreamgirls | Kurt Hummel and Mercedes Jones | 13. “New Directions” |
| “Party All the Time” | Eddie Murphy | Holly Holliday with current and former McKinley High students and Will Schuester | 13. “New Directions” |
| “Loser like Me (Acoustic)” | Original composition | Blaine Anderson, Sam Evans, Tina Cohen-Chang and Artie Abrams | 13. “New Directions” |
| “Be Okay” | Oh Honey | Rachel Berry and Santana Lopez | 13. “New Directions” |
| “Just Give Me a Reason” | Pink feat. Nate Ruess | Quinn Fabray and Noah Puckerman | 13. “New Directions” |
| “Don’t Stop Believin'” | Journey | New Directions and Will Schuester | 13. “New Directions” |
| “Downtown” | Petula Clark | Rachel Berry, Kurt Hummel, Blaine Anderson, Artie Abrams and Sam Evans | 14. “New New York” |
| “You Make Me Feel So Young” | Frank Sinatra | Blaine Anderson and Kurt Hummel | 14. “New New York” |
| “Best Day of My Life” | American Authors | Blaine Anderson and Sam Evans with Beat Club Crew dancers | 14. “New New York” |
| “Rockstar” | A Great Big World | Elliott “Starchild” Gilbert and Kurt Hummel | 14. “New New York” |
| “Don’t Sleep in the Subway” | Petula Clark | Rachel Berry and Artie Abrams with subway riders | 14. “New New York” |
| “People” | Funny Girl | Rachel Berry | 14. “New New York” |
| “No One Is Alone” | Into the Woods | Rachel Berry, Kurt Hummel and Blaine Anderson | 15. “Bash” |
| “(You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman” | Aretha Franklin | Mercedes Jones | 15. “Bash” |
| “Broadway Baby” | Follies | Rachel Berry and Blaine Anderson | 15. “Bash” |
| “Not While I’m Around” | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | Blaine Anderson, Rachel Berry, Mercedes Jones, and Sam Evans | 15. “Bash” |
| “Colorblind” | Amber Riley | Mercedes Jones | 15. “Bash” |
| “I’m Still Here” | Follies | Kurt Hummel | 15. “Bash” |
| “Addicted to Love” | Robert Palmer | Artie Abrams with Jessica, Julie, Vanessa and female admirers | 16. “Tested” |
| “I Want to Know What Love Is” | Foreigner | Mercedes Jones with church choir | 16. “Tested” |
| “Love Is a Battlefield” | Pat Benatar | Blaine Anderson and Kurt Hummel | 16. “Tested” |
| “Let’s Wait Awhile” | Janet Jackson | Mercedes Jones and Artie Abrams with Sam Evans | 16. “Tested” |
| “Lovefool” | The Cardigans | Rachel Berry with Blaine Anderson, Tina Cohen-Chang, Sam Evans, Kurt Hummel andSantana Lopez | 17. “Opening Night” |
| “N.Y.C.” | Annie | Sue Sylvester and Will Schuester | 17. “Opening Night” |
| “I’m the Greatest Star” | Funny Girl | Rachel Berry | 17. “Opening Night” |
| “Who Are You Now?” | Funny Girl | Rachel Berry and Sue Sylvester | 17. “Opening Night” |
| “Pumpin Blood” | NONONO | Rachel Berry with Mercedes Jones and Santana Lopez | 17. “Opening Night” |
| “Wake Me Up” | Avicii feat. Aloe Blacc | Rachel Berry | 18. “Back-up Plan” |
| “Doo Wop (That Thing)” | Lauryn Hill | Mercedes Jones and Santana Lopez | 18. “Back-up Plan” |
| “Story of My Life” | One Direction | Kurt Hummel and Blaine Anderson | 18. “Back-up Plan” |
| “Piece of My Heart” | Big Brother and the Holding Company | June Dolloway and Blaine Anderson | 18. “Back-up Plan” |
| “The Rose” | Bette Midler | Rachel Berry | 18. “Back-up Plan” |
| “I Melt with You” | Modern English | Sam Evans, Rachel Berry and Mercedes Jones with Artie Abrams | 19. “Old Dog, New Tricks” |
| “Memory” | Cats | Kurt Hummel and Maggie Banks with Lexington Home retirees | 19. “Old Dog, New Tricks” |
| “Werewolves of London” | Warren Zevon | Sam Evans and Artie Abrams | 19. “Old Dog, New Tricks” |
| “Lucky Star” | Madonna | Kurt Hummel and Maggie Banks with Lexington Home retirees | 19. “Old Dog, New Tricks” |
| “Take Me Home Tonight” | Eddie Money | Artie Abrams, Blaine Anderson, Maggie Banks, Rachel Berry, Sam Evans, Kurt Hummel,Mercedes Jones and Santana Lopez with Lexington Home retirees | 19. “Old Dog, New Tricks” |
| “Shakin’ My Head” | Original composition | Mercedes Jones with Brittany Pierce and backup dancers | 20. “The Untitled Rachel Berry Project” |
| “All of Me” | John Legend | Blaine Anderson | 20. “The Untitled Rachel Berry Project” |
| “Girls on Film” | Duran Duran | Sam Evans with Charlie Darlene and female models | 20. “The Untitled Rachel Berry Project” |
| “Glitter in the Air” | Pink | Rachel Berry | 20. “The Untitled Rachel Berry Project” |
| “No Time at All” | Pippin | June Dolloway and Blaine Anderson with concert audience | 20. “The Untitled Rachel Berry Project” |
| “American Boy” | Estelle feat. Kanye West | Blaine Anderson and Kurt Hummel | 20. “The Untitled Rachel Berry Project” |
| “Pompeii” | Bastille | Rachel Berry, Kurt Hummel, Mercedes Jones, Blaine Anderson, Sam Evans, Artie Abrams and Brittany Pierce with New York citizens | 20. “The Untitled Rachel Berry Project” |
